Fashion Features Other Lists Worst Oscar Best Picture Line-Ups Ever

The 10 Worst Oscar Best Picture Line-Ups Ever « Taste of Cinema

The 10 Worst Oscar Best Picture Line-Ups Ever « Taste of Cinema

Each single yr we now have the Academy Awards to spotlight the supposed better of the yr. The reality is more often than not the easiest are by no means really nominated. Now do I essentially care about what the Academy says, not likely. However the Academy is a prestigious institute that holds weight, it shines a highlight on movies which will or might not deserve it that then creates a ripple impact within the movie business.

There’s a cause phrases like “Oscar-Bait” exist, studios have taken observe of what the Academy sometimes nominates so they may exit of their approach to create movies like that. So if you now contemplate that the Academy locations particular guidelines of their system to restrict the quantity of movies that may qualify for awards, you begin to understand that the Academy calling something ‘Greatest Image’ is very questionable.

Within the 90 yr historical past of the Oscars I can trustworthy inform you those that there’s solely been 9 situations of the place the Academy gave the Greatest Image to what I actually felt was the number one greatest movie of the yr. To not say I hate most Greatest Image winners as a result of I don’t, I often just like the movies that win even when they’re not my no 1. However there are lots of situations the place they merely get it flawed. And that’s what I’m going to spotlight right here at present.

The occasions in Oscar historical past the place the lineup of Greatest Image nominees was, let’s say, lower than stellar. To not say each single certainly one of these was a nasty nomination, nor that the eventual winner was a nasty selection, however fairly to showcase what might’ve and by outward appearances ought to’ve been. So with that listed here are the 10 Worst Greatest Image Line-Ups, in no order aside from chronologically.


1. 1949: All of the King’s Males (Winner), Battleground, The Heiress, A Letter to Three Wives, Twelve O’Clock Excessive

All the King’s Men

Query, has anybody truly heard of any of those movies? For those who assume the Academy nominating common films for Greatest Image is a brand new improvement you’re sorely mistaking, this has been happening for some time. 1949 was a yr indicative of WWII crowd pleasers like “Battleground” and “Twelve O’Clock Excessive” and a couple of forgettable melodramas “The Heiress” and “A Letter to Three Wives”. The winner was “All of the King’s Males” and it wasn’t even an excellent film, it’s simply as forgettable as every part else nominated right here.

It’s an actual disgrace too as a result of whereas America was shelling out uninteresting movies this yr, different nations have been tearing it up. The British movie “The Third Man” was one of many greats of the last decade that confirmed Orson Welles talents as an actor in what I might name his greatest efficiency and demonstrated the directional talents of Carol Reed.

Akira Kurosawa made one in every of his biggest with “Stray Canine” that obtained the ball rolling with greats he would make in years to return. Yasijiro Ounces made the unimaginable “Late Spring” which is one other nice in his lengthy record of deeply religious movies and one of many all-time greats.

And to provide America some credit score we had the superb Raoul Walsh movie noir “White Warmth” which is cemented as one of many nice crime movies of all time. It’s been a development since virtually the daybreak of the Academy Awards that the yr’s greatest don’t actually get nominated like they need to and this was solely the start.


2. 1952: The Biggest Present on Earth (Winner), Excessive Midday, Ivanhoe, Moulin Rouge, The Quiet Man

The Greatest Show on Earth

“The Biggest Present on Earth” is just about all I’ve to say, extensively considered one of many worst winners of all time. The unhappy factor about that’s it was in all probability the 2nd better of the nominees. The unique “Moulin Rouge” is an uninteresting piece of the occasions, “The Quiet Man” is respectable movie however not certainly one of John Wayne’s greatest, and I dare you individuals to inform me something about “Ivanhoe”.

Then in fact there’s “Excessive Midday” which was undoubtedly the perfect of the bunch. It was fascinating for its construction and essential for its themes relating to American tradition and communism, however personally talking hasn’t aged very properly in comparison with most of the different classics.

It’s bizarre to assume that “Singin’ within the Rain”, the best of all basic musicals, wasn’t nominated for the grand prize this yr. Particularly when it’s coming off the heels of one other Gene Kelly musical “An American in Paris” that gained Greatest Image only one yr earlier than.

There additionally must be point out of Akira Kurosawa’s masterpiece “Ikiru” that continues to be one of many biggest movies ever made, Oscars have a monitor report of by no means recognizing overseas movies and this was no exception. And I’ll additionally point out the extremely unappreciated thriller “5 Fingers”, it’s not all the time talked about in the identical breath as different WWII spy thrillers like “Infamous” however it must be.

With a few years, no matter whether or not I prefer it or not, I can perceive why they nominated movies the best way they did. And I’ll elaborate on this as soon as we undergo extra of this record. However the movies of 1952 is one which has me scratching my head as a result of I actually don’t perceive why they went with the lineup they did.


three. 1955: Marty (Winner), Love is a Many-Splendored Factor, Mister Roberts, Picnic, The Rose Tattoo


There aren’t many Oscar lineups as clean as this one. The one one value speaking about was “Marty” which deserved the win out of these nominees, I imply what else might it have gone to? If there’s a ceremony that higher illustrates how the Academy thinks brief time period as an alternative of long run this may be the one. Each nominee was indicative of their time and by no means escaped it, attempt watching any of those now and also you’ll see how arduous it’s to take a seat via.

That is in all probability the one ceremony out of this listing the place I might’ve scrapped each nominee and changed it with one thing else, each different yr I’ll point out might’ve been higher however there might no less than be one and even two I favored. My 5 picks from this yr, and I’m positive everybody’s 5 picks can be “The Night time of the Hunter” which is likely one of the biggest of all basic movies even when it doesn’t all the time get the credit score for it. If there’s a greater wanting black and white movie I’d wish to know what it’s.

“Insurgent With no Trigger” and “East of Eden” have been additionally nice movies which are typically talked about in conversations of probably the most iconic of the 50’s decade. We had a severely underrated western movie “Dangerous Day at Black Rock” and one of many nice French movies of all time “Diabolique”. To be truthful I’m positive “Diabolique” was a movie that didn’t get acknowledged in America throughout this time, and within the custom of the Academy they in all probability weren’t involved with the opposite greats I discussed. Which is a rattling disgrace.


four. 1956: Across the World in 80 Days (Winner), Pleasant Persuasion, Big, The King and I, The Ten Commandments

Around the World in 80 Days (1956)

Nicely this one ought to go with out saying. When polls are carried out asking what the worst Greatest Image winners are, “Across the World in 80 Days” is all the time listed up there within the prime rankings. I do know that usually talking 1956 wasn’t probably the most stellar yr in historical past however there was definitely greater than what we acquired nominated right here.

The one movie out of those nominations that ought to even be remotely thought-about in rivalry is “Big” which is a superb epic. A sprawling, sly, and daring take a look at Texan society that went over massive and showcased what James Dean was able to, if solely he had lived longer.

The one different nomination that’s noteworthy can be Cecil B. DeMille’s “The Ten Commandments” which definitely holds a spot of fame within the annals of historical past, however with that being stated isn’t a totally realized challenge both. It definitely is an epic in each sense of the phrase however undoubtedly has its faults in path, appearing, writing, and biblical accuracy. All the things else is simply abnormal past perception.

The most important snub of 1956 is undoubtedly “The Searchers” which continues to face as one of many nice movies of all time, and positively some of the influential. Westerns have been the dominating style within the movie business for a very long time however in the direction of this time interval is once they began falling out of relevance, so I assume it’s comprehensible the way it didn’t get nominated.

Stanley Kubrick made his first nice movie with “The Killing”, a criminal offense heist image that was forward of its time however in all probability didn’t attraction to the previous guard in 1956. We had two science fiction classics “Forbidden Planet” and “Invasion of the Physique Snatchers” launched this yr that also resonate as two of the style’s most essential.

Alfred Hitchcock made some good movies this yr with “The Man Who Knew Too A lot” and “The Improper Man” which admittedly aren’t the perfect he’s made however are nonetheless so a lot better than a lot of the nominees we did get. After which in fact there’s the well-known Bing Crosby musical “Excessive Society” which is definitely probably the greatest the basic period of movie has to supply.

All in all 1956 wasn’t the perfect yr by any means, and the choice of nominees demonstrates how Hollywood was battling tv. As such they have been presenting probably the most epic movies they might to separate them from what t.v. was doing, no matter whether or not they have been nice or not.


5. 1968: Oliver! (Winner), Humorous Woman, The Lion in Winter, Rachel Rachel, Romeo and Juliet

Oliver! (1968)

The earlier yr of 1967 sparked a revolution within the movie business. With the releases of movies like “The Graduate”, “Bonnie and Clyde”, and “Within the Warmth of the Night time” the content material that movies might now experiment with was turning into vaster. With this breakthrough got here New Hollywood, a time interval of American filmmaking we’ll in all probability by no means see something like once more on a mainstream degree.

Sadly, as is typical with the Academy members, they weren’t fairly as much as degree with the present wave of expertise. It’s a historic incontrovertible fact that the Academy has predominantly been run by the previous guard and sadly the 1968 Oscars reveal this.

Nonetheless caught within the previous methods of previous nominees with two lower than superb musicals, “Oliver!” and “Humorous Woman”. One other film within the lengthy record of Shakespeare variations “Romeo and Juliet” that’s not the most effective adaptions. Paul Newman making a reasonably good shock with “Rachel, Rachel” after which an excellent interval piece “The Lion in Winter”. Besides this was less than snuff.

The most important omission from this yr’s Oscars is in fact Stanley Kubrick’s gold commonplace masterpiece “2001: A Area Odyssey”, unquestionably the most effective movie of 1968. It’s comprehensible in hindsight as a result of audiences and critics alike again then didn’t perceive what that they had simply witnessed in contrast to these days the place we’ve had 50 years of scholarly educating to enter our perceptions of it now. Besides it’s a bit of saddening to assume Kubrick’s solely Oscar win was a Visible Results class for this movie.

However including to Kubrick’s masterpiece we had 2 horror classics for the ages as Roman Polanski tapped into the fears of paranoia that was outstanding within the 60’s with “Rosemary’s Child” and George A. Romero gave us the final of the basic black and white horror movies with “Night time of the Dwelling Lifeless” which rewrote the guide for the zombie style. Rod Serling created one other thoughts bending actuality to reflect our personal with “Planet of the Apes” directed by Franklin J. Schaffner.

Abroad Sergio Leone crafted one of many best westerns of all time with “As soon as Upon a Time within the West” whereas Lindsay Anderson gave us a outstanding piece of the eras counterculture “If…”. John Cassavetes made one other milestone in unbiased cinema with “Faces” whereas Mel Brooks gave us a comedy basic with “The Producers”. Within the upcoming many years the Academy would get themselves again into gear and acknowledge the affect that was occurring, because the years went on they have been nominating increasingly more nice movies for Greatest Image however in 1968 there was nonetheless some progress to be made.

Pages: 1 2

window.fbAsyncInit = perform()
appId : ‘443536529018037’,
xfbml : true,
model : ‘v2.three’

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//join.fb.internet/en_US/sdk.js”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));
(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//join.fb.internet/en_GB/all.js#xfbml=1&appId=216138545139987”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));